My Favorite Pie: Aunt Lolita's Buttermilk Pie, Perfect for the 4th of July

Sorry folks, we ate all but one piece before I could snap a picture!

I'll admit it. As a child I ran from things containing buttermilk. I just assumed they would be...well...yucky. Perhaps because I'd seen my grandad eat cornbread crumbled in buttermilk out of a glass. (And no, I have never tried it, and never will, so don't ask.) Somewhere in my teenage years all that changed when I took a bite of my Aunt Lolita's Buttermilk Pie at a family reunion. Good could anything containing buttermilk taste so good!?! It quickly became my favorite pie. And I do like pretty much all pie. It's easy. It's delicious. And I even cheat on the crust by using a ready-made Pillsbury pie crust. I've probably made hundreds of these over the years. It's just a great go-to for company. And it's also great with sliced strawberries, or blueberries, or raspberries, or lavender-infused strawberry, or blueberry, or raspberry chunky syrup drizzled over the top. Perfect colors for the 4th of July. But best of all, whenever I make this pie, like so many of the family recipes I treasure, I remember the person who first shared it with me. And that would be my sweet Aunt Lolita (Cope) Wiley. (Those of you from Leavenworth High School will remember her as Mrs.Wiley from the counselor's office.) Thanks, Aunt Lolita!

Aunt Lolita's Buttermilk Pie
1 stick of margarine, melted
2 cups sugar
3 eggs
1/3 cup flour
3/4 cup buttermilk
1 t vanilla
1 unbaked pie shell

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Mix all ingredients with a hand mixer until well blended (or simply stir until well blended, which is what I do). Pour into the unbaked pie shell. Bake 35-40 minutes. Cool before serving. Can be stored at room temperature or in the fridge.
Note: The middle might be a little jiggly, but it will set up.

Yummmmmeeeeee! Enjoy!



Katie said…
I must admit this is one of my favorites! I have (attempted) to make it before and though the flavor was wonderful I didnt let it set long enough or....didnt follow the directions to a T and it was runny. What could I have done wrong?
CL Field said…
Maybe you didn't bake it long enough. Some ovens need the full 40 minutes. If the crust gets brown just cover it with a foil strip. Then try refrigerating it when it cools.
ginger said…
any recent new puppy pics??

Popular Posts